Analysis

Why Was Mohammed Siraj Dropped? Gill and Kotak Explain, Ashwin's 'New Normal' Jibe and What the Numbers Say

Why was Mohammed Siraj dropped for the NZ vs IND 1st Test, and why did Washington Sundar play ahead of Ravindra Jadeja? What Gill and Kotak said, Ashwin's post, and the Day 1 numbers.

··5 min read·16 views

Also read in: हिन्दी

India fast bowler Mohammed Siraj smiling at a public event
🔖 Bookmark (log in)

Why was Mohammed Siraj dropped? That has been the biggest question among Indian fans since the toss of the NZ vs IND 1st Test in Wellington on Thursday. India picked four fast bowlers on a green Basin Reserve pitch, and Mohammed Siraj was not one of them. Ravindra Jadeja was also left out, with Washington Sundar picked as the only spinner. Here is what captain Shubman Gill and batting coach Sitanshu Kotak said, what R Ashwin posted, and whether the numbers from Day 1 back India's call.

India's XI for the Wellington Test

India: KL Rahul, Yashasvi Jaiswal, Devdutt Padikkal, Shubman Gill (captain), Rishabh Pant (wk), Washington Sundar, Dhruv Jurel, Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj, Jasprit Bumrah, Prasidh Krishna.

Fast bowlers picked: Jasprit Bumrah, Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj, Prasidh Krishna. Left out: Mohammed Siraj, Gurnoor Brar, Ravindra Jadeja (plus Nitish Kumar Reddy as a seam-bowling all-rounder option).

What Shubman Gill said at the toss

Gill did not hide that it was close. "Quite tough, you know. We were contemplating for the past one week which combination to go with because all of our fast bowlers have been doing really well," he said at the toss (as reported by ABP Live). "Very difficult for Siraj and Gurnoor, for both of them to miss out."

There was no injury given as a reason. Before the match, Gill had said India wanted "someone who is bowling fast, someone who is tall" for the five days, which is the role Prasidh filled. We covered that press conference in our India playing XI preview.

What Sitanshu Kotak said after Day 1

India sent batting coach Sitanshu Kotak to the press conference at the end of a bowling day, and the Siraj questions kept coming. His answers, as reported by ESPNcricinfo:

  • On why Siraj missed out: "The team management, the captain, they pick the team, they see what is the best XI they can play, and I think everyone felt this is the best XI."
  • On whether something is wrong with Siraj: "There's nothing wrong. I can't see anything wrong." He added that Siraj had played both Tests in Sri Lanka in August, in different conditions.
  • On what India wanted: "Two [bowlers] seam the ball well, two swing the ball well. And obviously pace is one thing." He said that on a damp, grassy pitch India wanted height and bounce, and that the team was picked for all five days, not just the first.
  • His last word: "Siraj also is a world-class bowler... On the day, for this match, we thought this is the best bowling attack."

Why Washington Sundar over Ravindra Jadeja

According to ESPNcricinfo, Washington's off-spin was seen as the bigger threat to New Zealand's top four, who are all left-handed: Tom Latham, Devon Conway, Henry Nicholls and Rachin Ravindra. On Day 1 Washington bowled 16 overs for 38 runs without a wicket. Kotak said that let India manage both the over rate and the workload of their four quicks.

R Ashwin's "new normal" post

Former India off-spinner R Ashwin replied to a fan on X about the selection: "Harsh, very Harsh but this is the new normal." In a later reply he said the "new normal" line was meant sarcastically, according to The Cricket News (via Yahoo Sports). He did not name anyone. Head coach Gautam Gambhir's selections have been questioned often since he took over in 2024.

Did India get it wrong? What the Day 1 numbers say

India had New Zealand at 70 for 5 and finished the day at 243 for 5, so the debate was always going to get louder. Some numbers to weigh:

Bowler (Day 1) Overs Runs Wickets
Jasprit Bumrah 17 52 3
Anshul Kamboj 18 57 1
Akash Deep 15 33 1
Prasidh Krishna 16 58 0
Washington Sundar 16 38 0
  • The case for India's call: all four seamers bowled 15 to 18 overs, and no one went above four an over. Kamboj and Akash Deep can bat at No. 8 and 9, which helps India field seven proper batters with both Rishabh Pant and Dhruv Jurel.
  • The case against: after the first 30 overs the attack offered little with the old ball. ESPNcricinfo noted that a Siraj at his best, with his wobble-seam ball, would have offered more old-ball threat than Kamboj or Akash Deep did on Thursday. It also asked whether India could have given Siraj a run of ODI games or sent him to Wellington earlier to prepare.
  • Siraj's recent form: ESPNcricinfo reported he was noticeably down on pace in Sri Lanka in August. He joined the ODI squad in the middle of the New Zealand series (our report on that).

Our take: India picked four genuine fast bowlers and kept the scoring tight, which was the plan. But a 216-run sixth-wicket stand is exactly the kind of session where a bowler with Siraj's record in SENA countries is usually missed. Remember that it was Siraj's fifth-day spell at The Oval in 2025 that levelled the England series 2-2. If India struggle to finish New Zealand's innings, the question will follow them to Christchurch for the 2nd Test, which starts on 27 November.

For the full Day 1 story and scorecard, read our NZ vs IND 1st Test Day 1 report.

Sources: ESPNcricinfo (Kotak press conference and analysis), ABP Live (Gill at the toss), Yahoo Sports/The Cricket News (Ashwin's posts), The Hindu (Day 1 scorecard). Updated 20 November 2026.

Cover image: Mohammed Siraj at an anti-drug campaign event / Anand Anil, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

💬 Comments (0)

Log in or sign up to comment.

Read more